Share this article
Introduction: Why Your Broker Selection Matters
Selecting the right tenant representation broker is a pivotal decision in your office space journey. The right partner can secure favorable terms, identify ideal locations, and transform real estate into a business advantage. Conversely, the wrong choice may lead to missed opportunities, unfavorable lease terms, and spaces that fail to support your business objectives.
This guide provides seven essential questions to evaluate potential office tenant brokers, along with a detailed assessment framework to ensure you select a representative who truly serves your best interests.
The Critical Role of Expert Tenant Representation
Before diving into the evaluation questions, it's important to understand what's at stake. Your office tenant broker will:
- Represent your interests in a complex and often opaque market
- Negotiate terms that can impact your business for 5-10+ years
- Influence total occupancy costs potentially running into millions of dollars
- Help shape your workplace environment and employee experience
- Guide decisions affecting operational efficiency and flexibility
Given these high-stakes responsibilities, thoroughly vetting potential representation is not just prudent—it's essential for business success.
Question 1: "Do you exclusively represent tenants, or do you also represent landlords?"
Why This Matters: This foundational question addresses potential conflicts of interest that could compromise the objectivity of your representation.
What to Listen For:
- Clear confirmation they exclusively represent tenants, never landlords
- Explanation of their tenant-only business model and philosophy
- Transparency about their firm's overall approach to representation
- Understanding of the structural conflicts in dual-representation models
- Commitment to objectivity throughout the process
Red Flags:
- Dismissing conflict concerns as "theoretical" or "manageable"
- Suggesting landlord relationships provide superior access or information
- Defending dual representation as "standard industry practice"
- Vague or evasive answers about representation policies
- Emphasis on "Chinese walls" or internal separation policies
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: 100% tenant-only model with clear explanation of value
- Strong: Primarily tenant-focused with minimal landlord representation in different markets
- Adequate: Separate divisions for tenant and landlord work with clear protocols
- Poor: Regular representation of both sides with minimal concern for conflicts
Question 2: "What is your process for understanding our business objectives and requirements?"
Why This Matters: Effective tenant representation begins with a thorough understanding of your business—not just your real estate needs. The broker's discovery process reveals how they'll align space decisions with your broader objectives.
What to Listen For:
- Detailed explanation of their needs assessment methodology
- Questions about business strategy, growth plans, and operational requirements
- Interest in workforce demographics and employee experience
- Discussion of financial parameters beyond just rental budget
- Approach to balancing various stakeholder priorities
Red Flags:
- Focusing immediately on square footage and lease term
- Generic questioning without industry-specific considerations
- Rushing to property recommendations before understanding needs
- One-size-fits-all approach to requirements gathering
- Limited interest in non-real estate business factors
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: Comprehensive business-focused discovery process with multiple stakeholder input
- Strong: Structured needs assessment addressing business and real estate requirements
- Adequate: Basic questionnaire covering essential space and location needs
- Poor: Minimal discovery focused primarily on square footage and budget
Question 3: "How do you analyze the full economic impact of lease proposals?"
Why This Matters: Office leases are complex financial instruments where the headline rental rate often obscures the true economic picture. Your broker should provide sophisticated analysis that captures all cost components.
What to Listen For:
- Discussion of total occupancy cost modeling beyond base rent
- Analysis methodology for operating expenses and tax pass-throughs
- Approach to quantifying improvement allowances and other concessions
- Process for creating apples-to-apples comparisons between options
- Incorporation of financial metrics relevant to your business
Red Flags:
- Oversimplified focus on face rental rates
- Limited attention to operating expense structures
- Superficial analysis of improvement costs and requirements
- Failure to discuss present value calculations for different scenarios
- Generic templates without customization for your specific situation
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: Comprehensive financial modeling with business-specific metrics and scenarios
- Strong: Detailed total occupancy cost analysis with present value calculations
- Adequate: Basic comparison model addressing major economic terms
- Poor: Simplistic analysis focused primarily on base rental rates
Question 4: "Can you provide examples of successful negotiations for similar companies?"
Why This Matters: Past performance offers insight into the broker's negotiation effectiveness, market knowledge, and ability to deliver results for businesses similar to yours.
What to Listen For:
- Specific examples with measurable outcomes and savings
- Experience with companies of similar size and industry
- Negotiation strategies employed and their effectiveness
- Challenges encountered and how they were overcome
- Types of concessions and favorable terms secured
Red Flags:
- Vague references to transactions without specific details
- Examples that don't relate to your industry or requirements
- Focus on transaction volume rather than quality of outcomes
- Limited discussion of negotiation strategy or approach
- Reluctance to provide references from similar clients
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: Multiple detailed case studies with documented savings and similar requirements
- Strong: Specific examples with quantifiable results relevant to your situation
- Adequate: General transaction experience in your market and industry
- Poor: Limited relevant experience or inability to demonstrate results
Question 5: "How do you leverage market data to create negotiating advantage?"
Why This Matters: Effective negotiation requires comprehensive market knowledge and the ability to use that information strategically to secure favorable terms.
What to Listen For:
- Sources of market data and how they're verified
- Process for tracking comparable transactions and concession packages
- Approach to creating competition among multiple landlords
- Methods for identifying market opportunities and timing advantages
- Strategies for using market knowledge in negotiation scenarios
Red Flags:
- Reliance on published asking rates without transaction data
- Limited knowledge of recent comparable deals
- Generic market reports without specific negotiation application
- Minimal discussion of competitive leverage creation
- Over-reliance on relationships rather than market dynamics
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: Proprietary data sources with detailed comp information and strategic application
- Strong: Comprehensive market knowledge with clear negotiation methodology
- Adequate: Good general market awareness with basic negotiation strategy
- Poor: Limited market insight or inability to apply data strategically
Question 6: "How will you manage the entire process from search through occupancy?"
Why This Matters: Office transactions involve multiple phases and disciplines. Understanding the broker's end-to-end process helps ensure nothing falls through the cracks.
What to Listen For:
- Detailed project plan with clear milestones and responsibilities
- Team structure and specialized expertise for different phases
- Process for coordinating architects, contractors, and other vendors
- Approach to timeline management and potential delay mitigation
- Transition support from lease signing through occupancy
Red Flags:
- Vague process description without specific milestones
- Overemphasis on initial search with limited post-selection support
- Unclear responsibility delineation for different project aspects
- Minimal discussion of potential challenges and contingency plans
- Indication that service levels drop after lease signing
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: Comprehensive project management approach with specialized resources for each phase
- Strong: Well-defined process with clear milestones and coordination strategy
- Adequate: Basic timeline with general process overview
- Poor: Minimal process structure or support primarily limited to initial selection
Question 7: "How is your compensation structured, and how does it align with our interests?"
Why This Matters: Compensation structures create incentives that can either align or conflict with your interests. Understanding how your broker gets paid helps ensure their recommendations prioritize your needs.
What to Listen For:
- Transparent explanation of fee structure and payment sources
- Discussion of how compensation aligns with your optimal outcomes
- Clarity about potential conflicts in traditional commission structures
- Policy on project bonuses or other incentive arrangements
- Openness to fee structures that align with performance
Red Flags:
- Reluctance to fully disclose compensation sources
- Dismissive attitude toward compensation-related conflicts
- Insistence on traditional commission structures without alternatives
- Defensive response to questions about incentive alignment
- Unwillingness to consider performance-based components
Evaluation Criteria:
- Exemplary: Transparent structure with clear alignment to your success and outcomes
- Strong: Full disclosure with thoughtful explanation of alignment
- Adequate: Standard industry structure with reasonable transparency
- Poor: Limited disclosure or visible misalignment with your interests
Beyond the Questions: Additional Evaluation Methods
While these seven questions form a strong foundation, consider these additional evaluation approaches:
Reference Checks
Speak directly with recent clients, asking about:
- Actual vs. promised service levels
- Negotiation effectiveness and results achieved
- Communication style and responsiveness
- How challenges or problems were handled
- Whether they would use the broker again
Team Evaluation
Assess the broader team that will support your project:
- Meet key team members who will handle your requirement
- Understand their experience and specialized expertise
- Evaluate team communication and coordination approach
- Determine availability and dedication to your project
- Assess backup resources if primary contacts are unavailable
Market Knowledge Testing
Probe specific market knowledge relevant to your search:
- Recent comparable transactions in target buildings
- Current concession packages being offered in your submarket
- Knowledge of upcoming market changes (new developments, major lease expirations)
- Understanding of landlord motivations in specific properties
- Awareness of non-public opportunities that may be available
Process Demonstration
Request a walkthrough of their process using a relevant example:
- Have them demonstrate their requirements assessment approach
- Review sample property tour materials and selection criteria
- Examine financial analysis models and comparison tools
- Review sample lease abstract and negotiation strategy documents
- Evaluate project management tools and communication protocols
Conclusion: Making Your Broker Decision
Selecting the right office tenant broker is a critical business decision with long-term financial and operational implications. By asking these seven essential questions and using our assessment framework, you can identify representation that truly serves your interests and creates measurable value.
Remember that the best broker for your organization is one who:
- Provides truly objective advice without conflicting interests
- Takes time to understand your specific business objectives
- Leverages comprehensive market knowledge for your advantage
- Delivers sophisticated financial analysis beyond basic rent comparisons
- Manages the entire process with clear communication and accountability
- Aligns their success with your optimal outcomes
At Vestian, we put real estate to work for businesses worldwide by delivering objective guidance and personalized solutions. As tenant-only representatives, we combine global expertise with local insight to help you navigate complex office space decisions with confidence.
Contact our tenant representation experts to discuss how our approach addresses these seven critical questions and delivers measurable advantages for your business.
